娛樂滿紛 26FUN - Powered by Discuz! Board

標題: 費sir在曼聯的最佳收購 [打印本頁]

作者: 923123 時間: 2007-12-28 12:54 PM 標題: 費sir在曼聯的最佳收購

如題,我應為就係C朗同朗尼

無佢,曼聯今日唔會有咁既成績

作者: jsp 時間: 2007-12-28 12:58 PM

should be Eric Cantona and Ryan Giggs...Roy Keane as well....no doubt with that...

作者: supreme12 時間: 2007-12-28 01:28 PM

Ryan Giggs```唔系青练军咩？

作者: realraul 時間: 2007-12-28 01:28 PM

簡東拿...
舒米高...

作者: brightlee 時間: 2007-12-28 01:30 PM

That'd be impossible for C Ronaldo and Wayne Rooney, cos they were famous before they start their career in Man Utd
Ryan Giggs is coming from Man Utd youth team, that's impossible too,
Roy Keane was famous as he was in Nottingham Forest, that's impossible too

I think there'd be only 1 choice:
Peter Schmeichel (500,000)

Without him, Man Utd's dynasty couldn't be started... the first year when he played in Man Utd
Man Utd was jumping from bottom of mid-table to 2nd position

作者: vincent220 時間: 2007-12-28 01:36 PM

stam is a great purchase too
also vidic now

作者: Kian76 時間: 2007-12-28 02:15 PM

史譚、舒寧咸、約基、高爾、蘇斯克查、堅尼、維迪、舒米高、簡東拿、雲尼斯杜萊、C.朗拿度。

作者: jsp 時間: 2007-12-28 02:28 PM

Originally posted by supreme12 at 2007-12-28 01:28 PM:
Ryan Giggs```唔系青练军咩？

Originally posted by brightlee at 2007-12-28 01:30 PM:
Ryan Giggs is coming from Man Utd youth team, that's impossible too,

Ryan Giggs is from Manchester City youth actually....(what a lost..for ManC

)
they not giving him a futher contract , his so upset and Sir Alex step up his house front door at his 14th birthday...so, rise the best left winger of all time in the history of Manchester united..even english football~~

and...he used to be Ryan Wilson....Giggs is his mother's name...and he choose to use his mother's...he got some unhappy childhood with his dad....

[ Last edited by jsp on 2007-12-28 at 02:57 PM ]

作者: peikasiu 時間: 2007-12-28 04:49 PM

if only choose one player, I am sure is Giggs!

作者: ringo1969 時間: 2007-12-28 07:26 PM

舒米高law~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^o^

作者: iknow 時間: 2007-12-28 07:52 PM

簡東拿, 舒米高, 堅尼, 黑雙煞, 雲佬

無辦法之下夾硬縮少至6條友...

作者: 76 時間: 2007-12-28 08:03 PM

記憶中mu 當年想用1,500萬uk dollar 買舒利亞....不過買唔到...結果用150萬買so20.....當年so20一季聯賽入18球.!!之後係euro對拜仁果場入左關鍵性一球,令mu成為3冠...絕對物超所值

作者: johnlaisin 時間: 2007-12-28 09:35 PM

必數簡東拿&舒米高....

作者: ROY CHENG 時間: 2007-12-28 10:08 PM

必定係簡東拿!!!!

作者: shehboy 時間: 2007-12-29 12:37 AM

Originally posted by jsp at 2007-12-28 02:28 PM:

Ryan Giggs is from Manche...

咁講法一定係Giggs啦, 一個被球會放棄既學童, 值得幾多錢 ? 最後變成傳奇球星, 用足廿年, 經歷幾個皇朝, 身價唔知升值幾多倍, 幫曼聯立過幾多汗馬功勞, 呢方面無其他人可及.

而最抵死既係, 佢係响同市宿敵手上執過黎既, 呢樣至更加突顯佢係最佳收購 !

作者: ~心水~ 時間: 2007-12-29 01:12 AM

我會揀s20
giggs 可能o係其他球會都有好既左翼
但係就唔係間間都有一個甘於做後備10年一落場就交到功課仲入到決定性入球既後備殺手

作者: cwc_tkd 時間: 2007-12-29 06:32 AM

我覺得最醒o既唔係費格遜, 而係曼聯,
因為曼聯買左佢, 哈

作者: chicken 時間: 2007-12-29 09:56 AM

CANTONA!! First King of Ferguson Dynasty!

作者: Shaqleung 時間: 2007-12-29 03:51 PM

absolutely cantona and schmeichel......probably Steve Bruce?

Recent ge buying ng hai ng good, but not as significant as the previous one.....and coz the failure in Veron, Forlan made it look like he not good in buying ppl~~

作者: kuru 時間: 2007-12-29 04:03 PM

雲尼c達來~

作者: ringo1969 時間: 2007-12-29 04:18 PM

費sir在曼聯的最佳收購~~同一手收購~~~~~~

蘇斯克查~~~~~~~~傳奇20號

作者: shehboy 時間: 2007-12-29 06:42 PM

樓主無定義"最佳收購", 令板友用緊唔同既理解去討論.

從字面講, "最佳收購"即係外購球員之中的最佳者, 咁講法即係選非曼聯培訓出來的最佳球員, 購入價錢同購入前該球員的表現並唔在考慮之列.

但如果從較有意義的著眼點去理解(本人相信此乃樓主原意), "最佳收購"應該包含比較收購前後該球員的名氣,表現,身價的差別來考慮, 咁好自然一定係傑斯, 因為佢在被購入前只係一個細路, 仲要係被棄用既. 不過佢可算係特別例子, 除左佢之外, 蘇斯克查, 舒米高, 亦比較符合呢個準則, 雖然佢地當時已經係國腳級, 同傑斯仔過曼聯時差好遠.

所以, 講簡東拿或朗尼都唔係好啱, 因為佢地未過曼聯時在列斯同愛華頓已經好受注目,
雲佬就更唔駛講, 早已是荷甲神射手.

作者: glmleung 時間: 2007-12-29 07:42 PM

should be 舒米高, no one can replace his role up to now.

作者: fowlerhk 時間: 2007-12-29 08:36 PM

schmeichel of coz

作者: plicaplica 時間: 2007-12-29 10:23 PM

簡東拿, 舒米高

作者: 迷途小羔羊 時間: 2007-12-29 10:56 PM

其實傑斯一向廣視作曼聯既青訓出品
因為他在成為曼聯職業球員前，並未在簽下其他球隊既職業球員合約
咁算唔算收購呢？又或者咁同我地一般所認為既收購又是不是一樣呢？

如果是講翻一般人認為既收購
即是加入曼聯前已簽過其他球會既職業合約
絕對是舒米高同簡東拿
但前者會是第一~~
因為佢帶俾曼聯既成就是史無前例既三冠王
後者係第二
簡東拿是帶領曼聯步向輝煌既過程當中既一個重要人物

作者: kakashi82 時間: 2007-12-31 01:57 AM

當然係舒米高,邦比發掘加超值轉會費加世界級水準，幾十萬磅轉會費係邊到搵？同而家嘅所謂最佳收購，使幾千萬嘅ｃ７同朗尼簡直無得比～

作者: arthur8088 時間: 2007-12-31 02:10 AM

Originally posted by kakashi82 at 2007-12-31 01:57:
當然係舒米高,邦比發掘加超值轉會費加世界級水準，幾十萬磅轉會費係邊到搵？同而家嘅所謂最佳收購，使幾千萬嘅ｃ７同朗尼簡直無得比～

in early 90s, $500,000 GBP is kind of near or above average transfer fee...Cantona or Keano's transferring fee were like 1 to 2M that time....but it was already the highest fee in England...

Frankly, C.Ronaldo is Fergie's best signing after 99 Triple~~and the fee is very very reasonable...~~(kind of a bit low based on his current performance) but he's one of Fergie's best signing in his life~~definitely

作者: brightlee 時間: 2007-12-31 04:44 AM

I still think Schmeichel transfer fee was a little bit lower than average at that period.....
Do you know why? I remember in 1989, Crystal Palace broke the record to buy a goal keeper named Nigel Martyn for 1 million pounds from Bristol Rovers.....

作者: jackycannis 時間: 2007-12-31 08:38 AM

簡東拿、舒米高、傑斯、朗尼、c朗…
講吓講吓，都幾多！
費SIR真係好眼光！

作者: 196560711 時間: 2007-12-31 10:07 AM

簡東拿.舒米高
兩大神人

作者: amigofans 時間: 2007-12-31 10:18 AM

有d唔同意大家睇"最佳收購"既定義, 因為大家似乎只覺得"平買"後打起既,
先算有眼光, 買一d如朗尼或簡東拿既球員, 無咩咁巴閉, 因為大家都知佢地好...

所以蘇斯克查, 舒米高呢d順理成章成為大家首選,

個人都認為佢地呢類係好收購, 但其實"平買", 承擔既風險比較小,
以少搏大, 搏輸左大家唔覺, 搏到一個半個就會名流青史, 人人話你好眼光...

就以蘇斯克查為例, 有幾多朋友會知道當年仲有位挪威前鋒"尼夫蘭"
同佢一齊加盟曼聯....

個人反而覺得"貴買"而最後可以成功到既更可貴, 錢就人人都有,
但若果失敗後, 果種風險唔係個個可以承擔....

例如朗尼02年euro果種超新星式既光芒四射, 係英超領隊都睇得到,
問題係只有老費同卜比sir敢賭呢一鋪, 當年雲加侯利亞敢唔敢郁?

我講呢一點係想大家唔好忽視"貴買"既球員, 雖然人人睇到,
但唔係人人都敢買架, 萬一睇錯既, 炒魷都有知....

堅尼, 朗尼, 里奧雖然係天價, 但都係非常好既收購...

小弟覺得"最佳收購"如下...

1.堅尼
2.里奧
3.舒米高

[ Last edited by amigofans on 2007-12-31 at 10:19 AM ]

作者: brightlee 時間: 2007-12-31 10:41 AM

Originally posted by filter-052fans at 2007-12-31 12:18:
有d唔同意大家睇"最佳收購"...

em... Rio...
I disagree
he is still inconsistency............ maybe he believes himself too much.. sometimes I think he'd make some silly mistakes.....

作者: amigofans 時間: 2007-12-31 10:59 AM

Originally posted by brightlee at 2007-12-31 10:41 AM:

em... Rio...
I disagree
he is still inconsistency............ maybe he believes himself too much.. sometimes I think he'd make some silly mistakes.....

無錯, 但亦應該考慮, 無里奧之前既時代....

尤其stam走人後果一季, 白蘭斯加莊臣.....
真係打到嚇死人, 果季最後好似足足輸左10場...

作者: 處處吻 時間: 2007-12-31 03:02 PM

簡東拿

簡東拿加盟, 俾左當年仲係小朋友ge碧咸, 史高斯一班年輕球員一個好好ge學習對象, 以前碧咸接受訪問時講過, 當年佢地一班o靚仔, 響簡東拿身上學到最重要係"專業", 簡東拿操練從不欺場, 往往會早到遲退, 有咁ge前輩在場, 佢地更加唔敢偷懶, 而佢更加好似簡大帝咁, 自己不斷加操, 咁日後先有"七旋斬"一技傍身~

簡東拿雖然唔係三冠王ge一份子, 但佢卻係重要ge基石...

作者: Edgar_Davids 時間: 2008-1-1 01:52 AM

Carroll, Djemba-Djemba, Veron, Forlan....

作者: arthur8088 時間: 2008-1-1 11:04 AM

Originally posted by Edgar_Davids at 2008-1-1 01:52:
Carroll, Djemba-Djemba, Veron, Forlan....

You have miss a few more....

Massimo Taibi, Mark Bosnich, Liam Miller, David May

作者: kakashi82 時間: 2008-1-1 09:02 PM

Originally posted by arthur8088 at 2007-12-31 02:10 AM:

in early 90s, $500,000 GBP is kind of near or above average transfer fee...Cantona or Keano's transferring fee were like 1 to 2M that time....but it was already the highest fee in England...

物價通脹係事實,但如果費sir能夠將依家部份收購嘅金額控制係千鬆萬已經算係成功,所以c7嚴格黎講係一個成功收購,但唔係"最佳收購"..因"最佳收購"嘅定義係超值價錢,世界級水準,球員於球隊嘅影響性以至佢本身於球場外私生活是否檢點等等...c7千二萬收購算係超值, 但佢於曼聯嘅影響力始終唔及舒米高,負面嘅私生活,國際賽同朗尼嘅爭執,而且依然未擁有過國際賽冠軍(球會及國家隊)等..如果依幾點佢能夠改善,佢有力成為曼聯十年內最重要一員!!

作者: soccerking 時間: 2008-1-1 10:01 PM

樓主話明係最佳，緊係貼一個就夠啦，佢就係舒米高．．．．

作者: amigofans 時間: 2008-1-3 09:44 AM

Originally posted by arthur8088 at 2008-1-1 11:04 AM:

You have miss a few more....

Massimo Taibi, Mark Bosnich, Liam Miller, David May

唔同意卡奴爾係失敗, 因為從來只係替補球員, 後備龍佢已經交足貨,
david may亦無咩問題, 佢都係3冠王既成員之一...

米拿成本太小, 失敗亦唔見有咩損失, 科蘭700萬唔係太貴,
至少佢入波唔少得過同樣700萬既smith...

迪贊巴, 泰比, 華朗, 尤其保斯尼治, 相信無咩point可以反對...

如果要玩呢個既, 相信雲加, 侯利亞個list, 會長過水蛇d春...

作者: arthur8088 時間: 2008-1-5 06:32 PM

Originally posted by filter-052fans at 2008-1-3 09:44:

唔同意卡奴爾係失敗, 因為從來只...

Thought Carroll was signed as a substitute, but his performance was below the standard....like based on he's first choice goalie in Northern Ireland...and let's pick Van Dee Goew as an example, he was Schmeichal's back up, but he did a better job than Carroll, at least Van was not nervous on the pitch at all~~that's why i say Carroll was a kind of failure capture..

Personally, david May is my least favourite players in Man Utd...he had only played one good season football in Man Utd which was 95-96 season...he's slow paced, slow agility, and with a big belly~~~(I have never seen a professional soccer players with such a big belly~~) i was very scared when he was holding the ball in 99 FA cup final against Newcastle...

i say Forlan was a failure capture becuase he scored his first Man Utd goal after 20 official matches with Man utd....

and probably i had too much expectation from Liam Miller...as he was captured by Man Utd in jan by signing a pre contract...i thought he could have provided a great defense..like Keane..coz he was signed to replace Keane~~
but it turned out he was a mediocre player only~

歡迎光臨娛樂滿紛 26FUN (http://26fun.com./bbs/)